The short answer
Reupholster when the frame is sound, you like the shape and size, and the piece is well made or has sentimental value. Buy new, ideally made to measure, when the frame is compromised, the seat was never comfortable or the size no longer suits your home.
How to check the frame
- Lift one corner a few centimetres. If the sofa twists a lot or creaks loudly, the joints may be loose.
- Push the arms outwards. A moving arm needs checking.
- Look underneath if possible. Solid wood and good plywood can almost always be recovered; thin or damp-damaged boards are harder.
- Sit in different places. If you sink in one spot only, it is often the springs, not the frame.
These are rough checks: the real verdict comes when the sofa is opened up.
What can be rebuilt
| Work | When it is needed | What changes |
|---|---|---|
| Cover only | Padding still good, fabric worn or dated | New look, same seat |
| Padding | Sagging seat, flattened cushions | Comfort like new, firmer or softer |
| Springs | Sinking even with new padding | Stable, even seat |
| Frame | Creaks, moving parts | Solidity and lifespan |
What drives the cost
- Size and shape: a corner sofa or one with many cushions takes more material and hours.
- Inner condition: a new cover is different from rebuilding padding, springs and frame.
- Material: quantity and type, fabric or leather, weigh heavily on the total.
- Details: piping, buttons, quilting and visible stitching take time and precision.
- Logistics: collection, delivery and home measuring.
A few photos and rough measurements are enough for a first assessment.
Why saving at the start can cost more
Many mass-produced sofas have light frames and low-density padding designed to be cheap rather than to last: after a few seasons the seat gives way. Rebuilding a well-made sofa means investing in something that has already proved it lasts, this time with quality padding and cover. It is not always cheaper than a budget sofa, but it usually lasts far longer.
When a new sofa makes more sense
When the frame is broken or damp-damaged, the sofa was never comfortable, or you have moved and the size no longer works. Then a made-to-measure sofa lets you start from what was wrong with the old one.
